Favorite David Lee Roth-Era Van Halen Album?

When I first heard Sammy Hagar was joining Van Halen I was pissed. I revolted. I said no way in hell will I ever support such a thing. I felt that way for a couple of reasons. First, I love Sammy Hagar. I didn't want him to be part of a band. I wanted solo Sammy. Second, I couldn't imagine Van Halen without Diamond Dave up front. I went to see David Lee Roth on his solo tour for the Eat 'Em and Smile album (which I also bought), but it took me a bit longer to get on board with Sammy and Van Halen. When I finally did, I realized how good they were together. It doesn't detract one bit from how awesome the Eat 'Em and Smile album is, though. I still listen to it today. With Steve Vai on guitar, Billy Sheehan on bass, Gregg Bissonette on drums, and David's sparkling personality, it couldn't lose. I've always said it could have been the next Van Halen album if Dave had stayed in the band, and it would have been a damn fine effort.

But let's talk about the albums Dave actually did with Van Halen. Which one is your favorite? I know Dave had a reunion with Van Halen, so for the record, I'm only talking about the first six Van Halen albums. Those are Van Halen, Van Halen II, Woman and Children First, Fair Warning, Diver Down, and 1984. That's what I consider official Davide Lee Roth-era Van Halen.

The order of my favorites is:

Van Halen

Van Halen II

Women and Children First

1984

Fair Warning

Diver Down.

Van Halen is a classic and just exploded on the scene with fresh intensity. It has to come first. With the foundation tunes Ain't Talkin' 'Bout Love, Runnin' with the Devil, and the cover of You Really Got Me, not to mention Jamie's Cryin' and the groundbreaking Eruption, this album is first almost by default. There's times I believe I like the second and third albums just as good as the first, but in the end, running them in order of release is best.

Van Halen II has Dance the Night Away, Somebody Get Me a Doctor, and D.O.A. Need I say more? Those are great tunes and the rest of the album stands the test of time.

Women and Children First features the brutal And the Cradle Will Rock as well as Everybody Wants Some, Take Your Whiskey Home, and Could This Be Magic? Just some really neat shit.

1984 could easily have been in the top three, but I wanted to give the first three records their due, so I'll keep this one where it is. Jump, Hot for Teacher, I'll Wait, and Panama -- the list goes on. The keyboards threw some fans off, but I loved the songs and the sound of this one.

Fair Warning is my sister's favorite. To me the album doesn't really have any strong tracks, but the sound is good and the songs are okay. There are times I'm in the mood for it.

Diver Down was just a lazy record. Yeah, the covers of Oh, Pretty Woman and Dancing in the Street were cool and Where Have All the Good Times Gone? wasn't bad, but none of these were enough to support an otherwise lackluster album. Just my opinion.

That's it for me. Leave yourcomments and let me know what you think.

Five Great Guitar Players

My five players aren't going to be your five players. You can argue any list I come up with and I can argue anything you come up with. A list like this can be based on personal preference, technical ability of the guitarists in question, or any number of other criteria. In the end, my list is mine and yours is yours, simple as that. Hell, I could create a list now (which I will do) and change my mind tomorrow. My list, you see, is subject to my changing moods.

Keep in mind, I'm talking primarily about rock guitar players here. There are guitarists in other genres of music that are equally important and equally talented.

Right now, putting myself on the spot, I'd have to say:

Scott Gorham (Thin Lizzy)
Rik Emmett (Triumph)
Eddie Van Halen (Van Halen)
Alex Lifeson (Rush)
Jimmy Page (Led Zepplin)

Now let's examine my list in a little more detail. There are some glaring absences I'm sure some of you are already screaming about. Jimi Hendrix is a notable example.

I didn't base this list solely on technical ability. That's part of it, but I also took into account the influence each of these guitarists have had on other players, their creativity and originality, and my personal preferences.

And that's why Scott Gorham is at the top of the list. Thin Lizzy is my all-time favorite band, Scott Gorham has influenced many other guitarists, and he is a tasteful player. Those three points guaranteed him a spot on the list. Is he the most technically adept player around? No. Does that matter? No. To me, Scott is at the top of the list because he knows what to play and when to play it.

Rik Emmett plays with a great combination of technical ability and raw emotion. He's a melodic player who knows when to throw in the chaos, and he can play skillfully in a variety of styles.

Eddie Van Halen has to be included by default. The guitar players he influenced are too numerous to count. What Eddie did when he came on the scene was completely fresh.

Alex Lifeson is here because the guys from Rush are at the top of their game. If this was a list of top five bass players, Geddy Lee would be on it. If this was a list of top five drummers, Neil Peart would be here. The guys in Rush are on every list, simple as that. Alex Lifeson demonstrates his right to be here through sheer technical prowess, creativity, and his major influence on other guitarists.

No need to say much about Jimmy Page. The guy is phenomenal on a technical level, a creative level, and his influence on generations of guitar players just isn't up for debate. I think almost anyone who reads this will agree.

Now, if I had compiled this list with only my personal preferences in mind, I would have listed Ace Frehley instead of Eddie Van Halen. Whether Ace is an equal player to Eddie or not is subject to debate. They are two completely different players. Ace is a more pleasant player to me than Eddie. I like his sound better, his tone better, his note choices better.

And Jimmy Page, guitar god that he is, would've been replaced in favor of Angus Young. Is Angus a better player than Jimmy? Hell no. Not even close. On a technical level, Angus is lower on the totem pole than any of these guys, but he plays with raw emotion and pure instinct. I find that appealing.

NOTE: I added this after the original post, thanks to a guitar playing friend who I will also be interviewing later on. He pointed out that I left off Ted Nugent. Slap my ass silly, I did. And I love Nugent. Sometimes I think the wildman's personality overshadows his playing. Fact is, as Joe Metcalf pointed out, Ted doesn't get the respect he deserves as a guitarist. There were countless kids who grew up in the 70s who cut their teeth on Nugent and picked up the guitar because Uncle Ted showed them the way. He plays his ass off, has a distinctive style, nice note choices, knows how to milk a note for what it's worth, and certainly deserves a spot in this post. Thanks for reminding me, Joe.

There are other guitar players that could (and should) be on lists of great guitar players. Just think of some of the guys that have gone through Ozzy Osbourne's band. Randy Rhoads was off the charts. What would he be doing if he were still alive today? Jake E. Lee is another phenomenal player. What about Zakk Wylde?

You want more? Steve Vai, Stevie Ray Vaughan, Carlos Santana, Joe Satriani, and Eric Clapton. I feel almost ashamed I didn't mention Eric Clapton earlier. His phrasing, versatility, and commitment to the guitar make him one of the greats.

Keith Richards wasn't a great solo player, but is there a better rhythm guitarist anywhere? His sense of timing and his ability to choose the right chord voicing at the right moment are impeccable.

And then there's Chuck Berry and Les Paul, two guys who could be considered foundational in everything that has come after them.

I didn't title this blog post Top Guitar Players for a reason. There are too many top guitar players out there. I called it Five Great Guitar Players. I ended up listing more than that, and truth be told, I could keep going. I won't do that, though. I'll leave it up to you to post your comments. Tell me who you like on a personal level, who you feel should've been on this list, and who you believe I should've disregarded.